This blog will explain the background to the UK High Court’s recent decision in Wikimedia Foundation v Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology, and will outline lessons learned for firms wishing to influence future policy (regarding the OSA and beyond). It does not constitute legal advice, but instead emphasises the advantage of consistent, politically-conscious messaging when engaging legislators. The blog therefore focuses in particular on the first and second limbs of the claim, which were largely based on Ofcom’s advice to the Secretary of State — advice in itself informed by prior stakeholder engagement. Our conclusion, given Wikimedia’s example, is that companies may be best served by showing, pre-emptively, how burdensome regulation can harm their business and the public good, defined in political terms, rather than by making a more purely technical argument about the letter of the law and then hoping for favourable advice from an already overstretched regulator.
Harry Sidnell
Harry provides policy analysis, monitoring and advice to tech clients from Inline’s London office. Before joining Inline, he worked in the analytical department of a major outsourced insurance buyer and as a legal researcher with the Gatehouse Chambers Construction Team.
Harry holds a Bachelor of Laws (LLB) from the University of York.
Recent Posts
Search Results: How Wikipedia's challenge to the Online Safety Act makes a case for Outcomes-Based Influence
Written by Harry Sidnell on 29 Aug 2025
What does the AI Opportunities Action Plan offer businesses?
Written by Harry Sidnell on 21 Jan 2025
This blog identifies some of the key recommendations made in each of the recently published AI Opportunities Action Plan’s sections (investing in the foundations of AI, pushing on cross-economy AI adoption, and securing the UK’s future with homegrown AI), highlighting those which offer the most promise to AI developers or adopters. It will then consider how Inline is well-positioned to leverage its tech expertise and relations with government to assist businesses in realising their AI ambitions.